Birdwatch Archive

Birdwatch Note Rating

2024-12-07 21:18:42 UTC - HELPFUL

Rated by Participant: 9249648D4F7A73ABFB2D81150A38CBA7BAAC21E7027757BC6FE5FF3D45BFD96B
Participant Details

Original Note:

A crucial context is missing: the model acted this way after it was told to pursue a goal at any cost. So while this is a valid example of instrumental convergence, it didn’t happen spontaneously. The tweet’s author agreed it’s misleading: https://x.com/shakeelhashim/status/1865004134631391295?s=46 The paper: https://static1.squarespace.com/static/6593e7097565990e65c886fd/t/6751eb240ed3821a0161b45b/1733421863119/in_context_scheming_reasoning_paper.pdf

All Note Details

Original Tweet

All Information

  • noteId - 1865014823928705435
  • participantId -
  • raterParticipantId - 9249648D4F7A73ABFB2D81150A38CBA7BAAC21E7027757BC6FE5FF3D45BFD96B
  • createdAtMillis - 1733606322369
  • version - 2
  • agree - 0
  • disagree - 0
  • helpful - 0
  • notHelpful - 0
  • helpfulnessLevel - HELPFUL
  • helpfulOther - 0
  • helpfulInformative - 0
  • helpfulClear - 0
  • helpfulEmpathetic - 0
  • helpfulGoodSources - 0
  • helpfulUniqueContext - 0
  • helpfulAddressesClaim - 0
  • helpfulImportantContext - 0
  • helpfulUnbiasedLanguage - 0
  • notHelpfulOther - 0
  • notHelpfulIncorrect - 0
  • notHelpfulSourcesMissingOrUnreliable - 0
  • notHelpfulOpinionSpeculationOrBias - 0
  • notHelpfulMissingKeyPoints - 0
  • notHelpfulOutdated - 0
  • notHelpfulHardToUnderstand - 0
  • notHelpfulArgumentativeOrBiased - 0
  • notHelpfulOffTopic - 0
  • notHelpfulSpamHarassmentOrAbuse - 0
  • notHelpfulIrrelevantSources - 0
  • notHelpfulOpinionSpeculation - 0
  • notHelpfulNoteNotNeeded - 0
  • ratingsId - 18650148239287054359249648D4F7A73ABFB2D81150A38CBA7BAAC21E7027757BC6FE5FF3D45BFD96B