Birdwatch Archive

Birdwatch Note Rating

2024-03-22 10:33:50 UTC - HELPFUL

Rated by Participant: D241CC19AA9DBEDE0FCD4AEB3CBCDB9E0A1AFD2EAE560C7100DE5720C91341F1
Participant Details

Original Note:

Hospitals lose their protection if they are used to commit an act harmful to the enemy. https://www.icrc.org/en/document/protection-hospitals-during-armed-conflicts-what-law-says Al-Shifa was so used (you don't get 90 gunmen in a hospital that isn't being so used). https://www.telegraph.co.uk/world-news/2024/03/20/israel-kills-90-hamas-gunmen-raid-gaza-hospital/ - https://archive.ph/6XTHG Therefore, Al-Shifa lost its protection, and Israel did not commit a war crime.

All Note Details

Original Tweet

All Information

  • noteId - 1770874616845566177
  • participantId -
  • raterParticipantId - D241CC19AA9DBEDE0FCD4AEB3CBCDB9E0A1AFD2EAE560C7100DE5720C91341F1
  • createdAtMillis - 1711103630102
  • version - 2
  • agree - 0
  • disagree - 0
  • helpful - 0
  • notHelpful - 0
  • helpfulnessLevel - HELPFUL
  • helpfulOther - 0
  • helpfulInformative - 0
  • helpfulClear - 1
  • helpfulEmpathetic - 0
  • helpfulGoodSources - 1
  • helpfulUniqueContext - 0
  • helpfulAddressesClaim - 1
  • helpfulImportantContext - 0
  • helpfulUnbiasedLanguage - 0
  • notHelpfulOther - 0
  • notHelpfulIncorrect - 0
  • notHelpfulSourcesMissingOrUnreliable - 0
  • notHelpfulOpinionSpeculationOrBias - 0
  • notHelpfulMissingKeyPoints - 0
  • notHelpfulOutdated - 0
  • notHelpfulHardToUnderstand - 0
  • notHelpfulArgumentativeOrBiased - 0
  • notHelpfulOffTopic - 0
  • notHelpfulSpamHarassmentOrAbuse - 0
  • notHelpfulIrrelevantSources - 0
  • notHelpfulOpinionSpeculation - 0
  • notHelpfulNoteNotNeeded - 0
  • ratingsId - 1770874616845566177D241CC19AA9DBEDE0FCD4AEB3CBCDB9E0A1AFD2EAE560C7100DE5720C91341F1